mansfieldnewsjournal.com

Powered by You and The News Journal

Family Holidays

Guide to planning seasonal celebrations

Voters' Voices

Jobs, the economy and the 2004 presidential election

Holiday Movie Preview 2004

Multimedia slide show with capsule previews of upcoming films

Standardized Testing 101

A primer for parents

Deadly Weapons in Dangerous Hands

Special report about weapons of mass destruction

Losing Ground

Special report: Wetlands' demise ripples across nation

Iraq: After Saddam

Continuing coverage of the conflict in Iraq


Thursday, April 10, 2003
Making sense of death, liberation, celebration is no easy task





and Gannett News Service
Learn about Tomahawk
cruise missiles
Beyond smart bombs: High-tech weapons explained
Meet U.S. commanders directing the war
Learn about Iraq's most powerful men
Case against Saddam
Suiting up for chemical war
Saddam's rise to power
Key U.S. diplomatic players

On a warm night in February I stood on a balcony of a Baghdad hotel, looking across the street toward the Palestine Hotel, and argued for an invasion. I whispered. One never knew who was listening in Saddam Hussein's Iraq.

Thorne Anderson, a freelance photographer, argued for peace, a position I fully appreciated after spending a week with the overtly kind and gracious locals.

What was most telling about our debate was that we felt compelled to move it to the dusty balcony.

It was here that the traffic five stories below muffled our words. Neither of us wanted to be deported or hustled away by Saddam's secret police to Baghdad's notorious Abu Ghraib prison.

"Just the fact that we feel like we have to stand on the balcony in order to have a candid conversation, doesn't that say something about Iraq? Doesn't that alone suggest a need for change?'' I asked.

At that time, criticism of Saddam or his Baath Party was a capital offense, a law that can stifle thinking and creativity, I argued.

So it didn't completely surprise me that when Iraqis from Basra to Baghdad to Kirkuk were finally free to speak, they shouted. It was a celebration. The lid on this pot has been rattling for decades. The bully Saddam is gone.

But do thousands of Iraqis shown on TV represent the feelings of 23 million residents of Iraq?

In an upscale Internet cafe in downtown Amman, Jordan, about 30 middle-class Arabs watched TV in stunned silence as U.S. Marine Cpl. Edward Chin clambered atop a statue of Saddam in Baghdad. The silence broke when Chin draped an American flag over Saddam's face.

"There were audible gasps in the room,'' said Iraq Peace Team member Ramzi Kysia, an activist from Washington, D.C., who has been in Baghdad and is in Amman today. "No one could believe the arrogance.''

Kysia, a Muslim writer, said the defeat of Saddam and his Baath Party has Arabs and peace activists in Jordan feeling conflicted.

"On the one hand, people are happy to see Saddam fall; they know how terribly he hurt Iraq,'' he said. "On the other hand, people think it happened too quickly. (President) Bush will think he can invade any country he wants, whenever he wants.''

Kysia's voice is one in the chorus of dissent that maintains nothing good can come from violence. Even if it eliminates a tyrant. Even if thousands of Iraqis rejoice.

Costs of war

Anderson, 36, a native of Alabama who lives in Serbia and regularly works in Iraq, worried about civilians caught in the crossfire. Parents would lose children. Children would lose parents. American soldiers, Iraqi conscripts, and even journalists would die.

Like Hans Von Sponeck, a former assistant secretary general of the United Nations in charge of humanitarian affairs in Iraq, Anderson could not bear the idea of innocent people dying in the conquest.

When Von Sponeck left Baghdad in January to return to his home in Geneva, his heart was heavy with a sense of the inevitable.

"Many of the people who walk the streets of Baghdad today will not be walking the streets of Baghdad after the war,'' he told me one month before Bush gave Saddam 48 hours to vacate Iraq. "This enormous price that the Iraqi people would have to pay in order to have a regime change is totally unacceptable.''

The costs can initially be weighed at Baghdad's four main hospitals.

The International Red Cross reports that hospital wards are choked with patients, civilian and military. Iraqi officials, journalists and nongovernment organizations estimate that more than 1,000 Iraqi civilians have been killed and 5,000 injured. Untold numbers are missing.

Before the war, the United Nations had predicted something far uglier: the deaths of 100,000 civilians. But this war did not deliver carnage en masse. That means little for the families of Ali Sabah Eadan, 4; Abbas Esmaeel Abbas, 7; Malek Sabah Eadan, 7; Abeer Taha Abbas, 9; Husham Sabah Eadan, 10; Muhammed Taha Abbas, 12; and Nora Sabah Eadan, 14.

Al-Kindi Hospital surgeon Osama Saleh told the Iraq Peace Team that the children were hit by a missile near the old Diala bridge in Baghdad. Fifteen members of two families died. Their homes burned. The only surviving child was 12-year-old Ali Ismayal, who lost both arms and was badly burned.

Down payment on future

The night before I left Baghdad, I discussed the civilian cost of war with Kathy Kelly, a 2003 Nobel Peace Prize nominee from Chicago. Kelly was at a bowling alley at the Palestine Hotel with dozens of American, European and Iraqi friends.

I had just gone with Kelly to the Shiite region of southern Iraq where Saddam has allowed poverty to fester. Streets flood with raw sewage. Household trash goes uncollected. Children live in conditions unfit for dogs.

"Even if the U.N. estimates are correct and 100,000 Iraqis die from this war, isn't that a small price to pay for the liberation of 23 million Iraqis?'' I asked Kelly. "Isn't regime change the best thing for the future generations of Iraqis? For the children?''

This was Kelly's 20th trip to Iraq. She has lived in the slums of Basra and Baghdad. She has shared the cinderblock garage homes of large Iraqi families who are too poor to afford a real house. Kelly remains in Baghdad today, next door to the Palestine Hotel.

The question bothered her. She looked as if she had tasted something sour.

"They want change desperately but I think they are scared of war,'' she said. ``I don't think they would view war as a means of liberation. ... If even one person dies from this war it is too many.''

Last week, Dr. Saleh told John Lee Anderson of the New Yorker magazine that the Al-Kindi hospital had treated about 300 civilians injured by bombs. He said he did not expect 12-year-old Ali to survive.

"War always brings tragedy, fear, pain and psychological trauma,'' he said. "Personally, I feel that problems can be solved by discussion and negotiation and collaboration. When you use military power, it means your brain has stopped.''

This was the precise point Thorne Anderson had made on the hotel balcony. It didn't matter that Saddam's regime might be eavesdropping or that we could be deported or arrested for speaking freely.

The bombing of a sovereign nation without provocation would be an invasion, Anderson said, plain and simple.

It also would set a dangerous precedent. And perhaps create a free nation.


Back to top
General: Iraqi troops improve
The top U.S. general in Iraq said Wednesday that once Iraqi government forces take the lead in the war, the insurgency can be defeated and the American troop level reduced.

| USA TODAY | Wednesday, January 26, 2005 | 11:40 pm

Parties waging a polite battle to control Najaf
In this city, the holiest in Iraq to the country's Shiite Muslim majority, political rhetoric is heating up. But unlike in some places in Iraq, the debate here isn't focused on religion or historic ethnic divisions, and there's little violence.

| USA TODAY | Tuesday, January 25, 2005 | 11:34 pm

In Iraq, the question is: To vote or not to vote
A recent survey by the International Republican Institute found that 80% of Iraqis say they will probably vote this weekend. But unrelenting insurgent violence, the specter of post-election sectarian strife and confusion over complex ballots threaten to snuff out democracy before it can take hold.

| USA TODAY | Tuesday, January 25, 2005 | 11:17 pm

Politics popular in Shiite areas
In Basra and other parts of heavily Shiite southern Iraq, people are embracing politics.

| USATODAY.com | Thursday, January 20, 2005 | 11:51 pm

Lengthy ballots, ad blitzes contribute to confusion
Less than two weeks before Election Day, many Iraqi voters still are unsure about some basics, such as: Who are they electing?

| USATODAY.com | Wednesday, January 19, 2005 | 11:44 pm

Sunni leaders urge talks with insurgents to end 'stalemate'
Moderate Sunni leaders are urging the United States and Iraqi governments to change course and seek a cease-fire and negotiations with insurgents.

| USATODAY.com | Tuesday, January 18, 2005 | 11:46 pm

Female Iraqi candidates risk lives
Members of Congress who traveled to the Middle East over the weekend got a harrowing lesson on the high price of democracy.

| USATODAY.com | Wednesday, January 12, 2005 | 10:57 pm

U.S.: Elections will be credible
The Bush administration will consider the results of Iraq's elections credible even if most Sunni Muslims minority don't vote on Jan. 30.

| USATODAY.com | Wednesday, January 12, 2005 | 10:57 pm

2 Iraq cities, separated by politics, await election
Sadr City and Fallujah illustrate both the hopes and risks of Iraq's march toward democracy.

| USATODAY.com | Tuesday, January 11, 2005 | 10:58 pm

Polling places planned in Iraq's problem areas
The Iraqi Election Commission plans to set up polling stations in problem areas in Iraq despite insurgent attacks.

| USATODAY.com | Monday, January 10, 2005 | 11:03 pm

Court-martial begins for Abu Ghraib figure
The court-martial of Army reservist Spc. Charles Graner, the man portrayed as the ringleader in the Abu Ghraib prisoner-abuse scandal in Iraq, is set to begin Friday at Fort Hood in Texas.

| USATODAY.com | Thursday, January 6, 2005 | 11:47 pm

Iraqi expatriates fear being left out of elections
Iraqi-American groups say disorganization and overly stringent requirements are plaguing an ambitious effort to allow expatriates worldwide to vote in Iraq's Jan. 30 elections.

| USATODAY.com | Thursday, January 6, 2005 | 10:48 pm

Allawi: Elections will go on
Iraqi interim Prime Minister Ayad Allawi on Wednesday rejected growing calls for postponement of the national elections set for Jan. 30.

| USATODAY.com | Wednesday, January 5, 2005 | 11:15 pm

Fallujans reluctant to return
So far, Fallujans are not lining up to return to what's left of their devastated city.

| USATODAY.com | Wednesday, January 5, 2005 | 11:13 pm

Congress expects $100 billion war request
Congress expects the White House to request as much as $100 billion this year for war and related costs in Iraq and Afghanistan, congressional officials say.

| USA TODAY | Monday, January 3, 2005 | 11:30 pm

More contracts steered to Iraqi firms
The U.S. government is shifting more reconstruction contracts toward Iraqi companies as violence makes it harder for American contractors to work.

| USATODAY.com | Monday, January 3, 2005 | 11:00 pm

Iraqi election candidates crave coverage
As Iraq moves toward elections scheduled for Jan. 30, the media campaign is intensifying.

| USATODAY.com | Sunday, January 2, 2005 | 10:57 pm

Gas shortage fuels resentment in Iraq
Buying gasoline in Iraq is a serious undertaking. Determined motorists get up before their dawn prayers to join 2-mile-long lines. Sometimes they don't get to fill their tanks until evening. A black market is thriving.

| USA TODAY | Wednesday, December 29, 2004 | 11:47 pm

Soldiers saw giant tent as inviting target for insurgents
Soldiers at the Forward Operating Base Marez near Mosul, Iraq base had long complained of feeling defenseless in the fabric-covered hall, which lately has been the target of mortar and rocket attacks almost daily.

| USA TODAY | Wednesday, December 22, 2004 | 11:42 pm

U.S. contractor pulls out of Iraq rebuilding project
A Virginia company this week became the first large contractor to withdraw from the multibillion-dollar Iraq reconstruction drive, saying work there was too dangerous and costly.

| USA TODAY | Wednesday, December 22, 2004 | 11:35 pm

Mosul attack showcases insurgents' intelligence
The implications of the audacious suicide attack in the center of a heavily guarded U.S. military base in Mosul go beyond a failure of base security.

| USATODAY.com | Wednesday, December 22, 2004 | 11:11 pm

Mosul blast hits U.S. hard
A massive lunchtime explosion struck a flimsy mess tent filled with soldiers Tuesday at a military base near Mosul. It was one of the deadliest attacks yet against Americans in Iraq. Mlitary spokesmen in Baghdad and at the Pentagon said 19 U.S. soldiers were killed.

| USA TODAY | Tuesday, December 21, 2004 | 11:45 pm

Soldiers who led invasion must return
Continuing insurgent attacks have forced the United States to boost its force in Iraq toward 150,000, its highest level yet.

| USATODAY.com | Sunday, December 19, 2004 | 11:08 pm

Chaplain, others look to lift Christmas spirit in war zone
Across Iraq, military chaplains will enter makeshift chapels on the morning of Dec. 25 and pray for peace on earth in a land where peace continues to be in short supply.

| Gordon Trowbridge | Marine Corps Times | Sunday, December 19, 2004 | 6:41 pm

Troops can't beat deals at PX
Flush with hazardous-duty pay and tax-free earnings, U.S. troops in combat zones often have more money to spend than things to buy. That's where the PX, or post exchange, comes in, providing a taste of home if only for the time it takes to eat a bag of Doritos.

| C. Mark Brinkley | Army Times | Thursday, December 16, 2004 | 11:22 pm

Army spending billions on new armored vehicles
The Army said Wednesday that it is spending $4.1 billion to armor all military wheeled vehicles in Iraq by June.

| USATODAY.com | Wednesday, December 15, 2004 | 11:23 pm

Air Force boosts number of supply flights
Roads have become too dangerous for American convoys, the top Air Force general said Tuesday.

| USATODAY.com | Tuesday, December 14, 2004 | 11:32 pm

Army Guard now says its Iraq troops figure was inaccurate
The Army National Guard said Monday it had given USA TODAY an inaccurate count of the total number of Guard troops in Iraq since the beginning of the war in March 2003, but still could not provide a precise count.

| Dave Moniz | USA TODAY | Tuesday, December 14, 2004 | 10:29 am

Fair vote possible in Anbar, top Marine says

The U.S. military believes Iraq's rebellious Anbar province can be brought into national elections scheduled for January.

| Gordon Trowbridge | Army Times | Sunday, December 12, 2004 | 11:05 pm

U.S. military preparing restive Iraqi province for elections
The top U.S. officer in Iraq's rebellious Anbar province believes the region can be settled and brought into national elections scheduled for Jan. 30. Anbar, a hotbed of insurgent unrest, stretches from west of Baghdad to the Syrian border and poses perhaps the toughest challenge to the U.S. mission in Iraq.

| Gordon Trowbridge | Army Times | Friday, December 10, 2004 | 9:09 pm


© 2003, Gannett News Service